Sunday 11 November 2012

Remembrance



The nation stopped for a few moments today to remember the war dead.   The Queen led the tributes, willingly as she will remember the war clearly, Prince Phillip followed, and he knows war having won an award for his work in one naval action long before he was important.  In towns and cities up and down the land groups large and small commemorated the dead.  Many people concentrate their thoughts on friends and families from major wars of the past, some young women think only of fallen husbands and brothers from recent days.  Men wounded in action pass by the Cenotaph glad they still can, others recently injured watch on TV.  

Someone unknown remembered Leslie Eley Wall who died on the disasterous Dieppe raid in 1942.  He is not on our memorial and I wonder who placed this cross here today.  Most of the 6000 participants who landed at Dieppe that morning were Canadian.  Half the force was lost.  Because the smart, often ageing, soldiers who pass by the memorials surrounded by bright red poppy wreaths do not convey what many servicemen know to be the truth of war I post two pictures from the raid. 



I don't post for 'shock' effect merely to show what many men endured.  Dead men lie around as if sleeping.  Some died immediately some died slowly possibly in pain, maybe concussed.   It is a sight that contrasts with the neat memorials which often hide the terrors of war.  The sight we can see, the smell, the fear, the pain we avoid.

War will always be with us, human nature will see to that, however we must show what the real cost is.  Too few politicians today know the cost, ours were youths in the 'Punk' era!  The constant flood of war films and games and television coverage of battles far away tend to take from us the reality of war, a reality our mothers and grandmothers understood without actually well enough.   My great nephew was lucky enough when in his last year at school they visited the war cemeteries in France.   While he is unlikely to begin a major war himself, a few minor ones possibly, all will remember what they saw and the cost of war.  Recruits to the British Army are now taken on such a tour I understand to ensure they realise just what service may mean.  Few can enlist with any misunderstandings about that today.

I wonder however about our remembrance.  Almost all football teams in the UK now wear a poppy on their shirt.  Every game has a minute silence, soldiers at most grounds get free entry, all pay respects.  Only occasionally does a player refuse to wear the poppy, one was hounded by the Daily Mail for this today.  This man, an Irishman, felt it wrong for him to do this, the paper decided to pick him out as if he was a criminal.  How strange I thought, we saw millions die in a fight for freedom from Fascism and a paper with Fascist sympathies attacks a man for taking that freedom to think for himself!   Too often people join in because it is a passing fancy, in a few years they will once again fall away.  Emotional blackmail helps no-one.  Today there is great support for the fighting men we ought to encourage this and demand our governments do more to care for such when they return broken, but maybe that is asking too much.



7 comments:

A. said...

Although your pictures do give a better picture of the reality of war, some of the war graves really bring home the sheer waste of life. In the large cemeteries you can't help but be struck by the enormous numbers of lives lost, and even the smaller ones, in some parts of France and Belgium they occur so often, little pockets of graves here there and everywhere. You can't help but be moved.

Adullamite said...

A, You are of course correct, but I was trying to evade the somewhat sentimental approach that occurs all to often. The results of war need to be realistic, and emotion enough for the people involved.
I almost put up one of the French cemetery pictures but could not decide which, there are so many.

Unknown said...

'Tis another very well presented piece, my friend.

Jenny Woolf said...

Absolutely agree. And they could start by setting up better methods of dealing with post traumatic stress syndrome. Most of the ex soldiers I know just don't want to talk about things. I suppose that is the traditional way of dealing with stress, but not everyone is capable of it.

Adullamite said...

Jerry, Thanks.

Jenny, Old soldiers never talk except to other old soldiers. It is well known they can only understand who have been there. However more could be done to bring them together!

Unknown said...

This is quite peculiar, my Uncle posted a link to this page this afternoon as a random find. Myself and my mum put a cross down for Leslie as he was Great Grandfather.

That there is my mums writing, but I myself put it in the Public Gardens every year and have done for quite some time now.

Adullamite said...

Rebecca, That's most interesting. I did a check on him and can find very little. He appears to have served under the name Griffin for some reason.
Rank: Private
Service No: B/88694
Date of Death: 19/08/1942
Regiment/Service: Royal Regiment of Canada, R.C.I.C.
Grave Reference: A. 19.
Cemetery: DIEPPE CANADIAN WAR CEMETERY, HAUTOT-SUR-MER
Additional Information: (served as GRIFFIN, W. L.).

He certainly picked an unfortunate episode to be part off.